In honor of Juneteenth, Billboard has stirred the pot with a freshly published list of the 75 Greatest R&B Singers of All Time and it’s already igniting spirited debates across social media. The big reveal? Stevie Wonder sits at the very top.

While many would agree that the Motown legend’s influence is immeasurable, not everyone is thrilled about how the rankings played out, especially when beloved icons like Beyoncé, Michael Jackson, Aretha Franklin, and Prince didn’t claim the top spot.

According to Billboard, their editorial staff evaluated singers based on several key criteria: vocal prowess, body of work, career longevity, industry achievements, game-changing influence, and enduring cultural impact. Notably, songwriting and group-based legacies weren’t a major focus—meaning legendary group frontmen and songwriters may have been edged out.

Based on those factors, their Top 10 lineup is as follows:

1. Stevie Wonder

2. Aretha Franklin

3. Michael Jackson

4. Beyoncé

5. Whitney Houston

6. James Brown

7. Prince

8. Mariah Carey

9. R. Kelly

10. Marvin Gaye

Unsurprisingly, the internet wasted no time dissecting the list.

Reactions on X (formerly Twitter) have been split. While some fans praised the recognition of Stevie Wonder’s enduring influence and genre-defining catalog—which includes classics like “Superstition” and “Signed, Sealed, Delivered I’m Yours”—others felt that more contemporary voices were shortchanged.

“Stevie is a genius, no doubt. But how is Beyoncé not number one after all she’s done for modern R&B?” one user asked.

Another chimed in:

“Michael Jackson was robbed. He’s not just an R&B star—he’s the blueprint for global music stardom.”

Elsewhere, fans lobbied for the inclusion of legendary artists left out of the top 10 altogether.

“I’m not sure who has to go, but Anita Baker belongs in the top 10,” one comment read.

“Where is Luther Vandross? That #9 spot should’ve been his,” said another.

A Generational Divide?

Much of the debate seems to come down to generational preferences. Older music fans are applauding the list for honoring the foundational artists who helped shape the sound and soul of R&B. But younger audiences are questioning the omission—or lower rankings—of 21st-century icons like Rihanna, Alicia Keys, and SZA, who’ve redefined the genre for a new era.

That tension isn’t new. Every time a “Greatest of All Time” list appears, it challenges the boundaries between legacy and innovation, commercial success and cultural impact, and pure vocal talent versus genre expansion.